1150GS vs 1200GS

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Three_of_Seven

Three_of_Seven

Pack Dog
WD Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2017
Messages
177
Reaction score
85
Location
Riebeek East
Bike
BMW R1200GS Adventure
Greetings everyone,

As part of my search for the "correct" replacement motorcycle; I am considering either a 1150GS or the replacement model 1200GS. In terms of upkeep / maintenance / availability of parts; what would you recommend, if the sole purpose of the motorcycle would be for commuting purposes?

Some might say rather consider the F800GS because it is lighter on fuel; but the cost of an older F800 does not justify the means. Some dealers say that the 1150's give too many problems, but they don't have any on their shop floor ... only the 1200's ... is this becasue guys don't want to part with the 1150 because of its reliability?

Your comments / suggestions would be greatly appreciated.


PS: The images displayed are of a 2003 model 1150GS with 32,000km on the clock which I found and considering to purchase ...
 

Attachments

  • 1150GS_1.jpg
    1150GS_1.jpg
    73.3 KB
  • 1150GS_2.jpg
    1150GS_2.jpg
    51.3 KB
  • 1150GS_3.jpg
    1150GS_3.jpg
    77.2 KB
  • 1150GS_4.jpg
    1150GS_4.jpg
    51.6 KB
  • 1150GS_5.jpg
    1150GS_5.jpg
    43.9 KB
  • 1150GS_6.jpg
    1150GS_6.jpg
    90.4 KB
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsman Max Formula Spray Pump 40% DEET, Repels Mosquitoes, Ticks and Gnats, Effective Long-Lasting Protection, 40% DEET (Pump Spray) 6 fl Ounce
$12.99 ($2.16 / Fl Oz)
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsman Max Formula Spray Pump 40% DEET, Repels Mosquitoes, Ticks and Gnats, Effective Long-Lasting Protection, 40% DEET (Pump Spray) 6 fl Ounce Tool Collection Technologies
Compression Packing Cubes, Organizers for Travel (National Park)
$54.95
Compression Packing Cubes, Organizers for Travel (National Park) TRIPPED Travel Gear
ILM Off Road Motorcycle Dual Sport Helmet Full Face Sun Visor Dirt Bike ATV Motocross Casco DOT Certified Model 606V(Matte Black, L)
$109.99
ILM Off Road Motorcycle Dual Sport Helmet Full Face Sun Visor Dirt Bike ATV Motocross Casco DOT Certified Model 606V(Matte Black, L) ILMotor
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsman Max Formula, Repels Mosquitoes, Ticks and Gnats, Effective Long-Lasting Protection, 40% DEET (Aerosol) 6 fl Ounce (Pack of 2)
$18.30 ($1.52 / Fl Oz)
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsman Max Formula, Repels Mosquitoes, Ticks and Gnats, Effective Long-Lasting Protection, 40% DEET (Aerosol) 6 fl Ounce (Pack of 2) Al-Khair Store
First Aid Only 299 Piece All-Purpose Emergency First Aid Kit (FAO-442)
$25.36
First Aid Only 299 Piece All-Purpose Emergency First Aid Kit (FAO-442) Amazon.com
Aerotrunk Compression Packing Cubes for Travel - Luggage Organizer Bags - Double Zipper Packing Cubes for Suitcases (6-Pack, Grey)
$59.99 ($10.00 / Count)
Aerotrunk Compression Packing Cubes for Travel - Luggage Organizer Bags - Double Zipper Packing Cubes for Suitcases (6-Pack, Grey) Intent Brands USA
ScorpionEXO AT960 Modular Adventure Street Adult Motorcycle Helmet with Bluetooth Ready Speaker Pockets DOT ECE Approved (Topographic Sand Large)
$299.95
ScorpionEXO AT960 Modular Adventure Street Adult Motorcycle Helmet with Bluetooth Ready Speaker Pockets DOT ECE Approved (Topographic Sand Large) Everything Ecom
OUMURS Adult ATV Dirt Bike Helmet with Goggles Gloves & Mask Adjustable Sun Visor Motorcycle Adult Helmet Off-Road Motocross Downhill Moped MX for Unisex-Adult-Matte Black, XL
$84.95
OUMURS Adult ATV Dirt Bike Helmet with Goggles Gloves & Mask Adjustable Sun Visor Motorcycle Adult Helmet Off-Road Motocross Downhill Moped MX for Unisex-Adult-Matte Black, XL OUMURS MOTORPARTS
Hi-Spec Tools 67Pc Metric Auto Mechanic Tool Set, Motorcycle & Car Tool Kit, Auto Repair Tool Set with Pliers, Screwdriver Set, Socket Kit & Tool Box Storage Case for Cars, Trucks, Boats RVs & Jeeps
-10%
$44.99 $49.99
Hi-Spec Tools 67Pc Metric Auto Mechanic Tool Set, Motorcycle & Car Tool Kit, Auto Repair Tool Set with Pliers, Screwdriver Set, Socket Kit & Tool Box Storage Case for Cars, Trucks, Boats RVs & Jeeps Hi-Spec Products, Inc.
BAGAIL 10 Set Packing Cubes Various Sizes Packing Organizer for Travel Accessories Luggage Carry On Suitcase-Black
$24.99
BAGAIL 10 Set Packing Cubes Various Sizes Packing Organizer for Travel Accessories Luggage Carry On Suitcase-Black Bagail
Motorcycle Helmet Holder Wall Mount, Motorcycle Helmet Rack, Helmet Stand Helmet Hanger Motorcycle Helmet Accessories with 4 Clips and 4 Hooks
-10%
$35.99 $39.99
Motorcycle Helmet Holder Wall Mount, Motorcycle Helmet Rack, Helmet Stand Helmet Hanger Motorcycle Helmet Accessories with 4 Clips and 4 Hooks Yustuf Direct
BAGAIL 4 Set/6 Set Compression Packing Cubes Travel Accessories Expandable Packing Organizers(Black ClothPattern 4 Set)
-30%
$18.99 $26.99
BAGAIL 4 Set/6 Set Compression Packing Cubes Travel Accessories Expandable Packing Organizers(Black ClothPattern 4 Set) Bagail
Shacke 8 Set Packing Cubes for Travel Lightweight Luggage Organizer (Cream)
$24.99
Shacke 8 Set Packing Cubes for Travel Lightweight Luggage Organizer (Cream) Shacke
Compression Packing Cubes for Travel - Luggage and Backpack Organizer Packaging Cubes for Clothes (Rainbow colors, 6 Piece Set)
-50%
$12.49 ($2.08 / Count) $24.99 ($4.16 / Count)
Compression Packing Cubes for Travel - Luggage and Backpack Organizer Packaging Cubes for Clothes (Rainbow colors, 6 Piece Set) The Pride Colors
Magnificent Motorcycle Trips of the World: 38 Guided Tours from 6 Continents
$19.99
Magnificent Motorcycle Trips of the World: 38 Guided Tours from 6 Continents Amazon.com
SING F LTD 7PCS Motorcycle Maintenance Tools Kit Portable Screwdriver Wrench 8-10mm 12-14mm 14-17mm Spark Plug Sleeve Plier for Motorcycle Repair Tool
$14.29
SING F LTD 7PCS Motorcycle Maintenance Tools Kit Portable Screwdriver Wrench 8-10mm 12-14mm 14-17mm Spark Plug Sleeve Plier for Motorcycle Repair Tool SING F LTD
LEXIVON Bike Torque Wrench 1/4-Inch Dr. 15-Piece Kit | 72-Tooth Gear, Dual-Direction Click Type 2~26 Nm / 17.7~230.1 in-lb (LX-191)
$59.97 ($4.00 / Count)
LEXIVON Bike Torque Wrench 1/4-Inch Dr. 15-Piece Kit | 72-Tooth Gear, Dual-Direction Click Type 2~26 Nm / 17.7~230.1 in-lb (LX-191) LEXIVON
BAGAIL 8 Set Packing Cubes Luggage Packing Organizers for Travel Accessories (Aqua Color)
-29%
$16.99 ($2.12 / Count) $23.88 ($2.98 / Count)
BAGAIL 8 Set Packing Cubes Luggage Packing Organizers for Travel Accessories (Aqua Color) Bagail
Motorcycle Guide Austria - the 50 Most Scenic Tours Road Atl
$11.67
Motorcycle Guide Austria - the 50 Most Scenic Tours Road Atl momox Shop
Poygik Premium 420 Piece Large First Aid Kit for Home, Car, Travel, Camping, Truck, Hiking, Sports, Office, Vehicle & Outdoor Emergencies - Emergency Medical Kits, Businesses & Home Medical Supplies
-40%
$39.91 ($39.91 / Count) $65.98 ($65.98 / Count)
Poygik Premium 420 Piece Large First Aid Kit for Home, Car, Travel, Camping, Truck, Hiking, Sports, Office, Vehicle & Outdoor Emergencies - Emergency Medical Kits, Businesses & Home Medical Supplies POYGIK
Odinsberg Motorcycle Tool Roll Bag Tools NOT Included - Small Tool Bag Wrench Roll Up Tool Bag Organizer Pouch Wrap Motorcycle Tool Kit Box For Harley Enduro Dirt Bike UTV Motorcycle Accessories Gear
-6%
$29.90 $31.90
Odinsberg Motorcycle Tool Roll Bag Tools NOT Included - Small Tool Bag Wrench Roll Up Tool Bag Organizer Pouch Wrap Motorcycle Tool Kit Box For Harley Enduro Dirt Bike UTV Motorcycle Accessories Gear Odinsberg
Motorcycle Trip Journal: Travel Log Book with Writing Prompts for Bikers and Motorcyclists
$7.25
Motorcycle Trip Journal: Travel Log Book with Writing Prompts for Bikers and Motorcyclists Amazon.com
ILM Adult Dirt Bike Helmets Motocross ATV Dirtbike BMX MX Offroad Full Face Motorcycle Helmet, DOT Approved Model 128S (Matte Black, Adult-L)
$69.99
ILM Adult Dirt Bike Helmets Motocross ATV Dirtbike BMX MX Offroad Full Face Motorcycle Helmet, DOT Approved Model 128S (Matte Black, Adult-L) ILMotor
God's Maps: Stories of Inspiration and Direction for Motorcycle Riders
$2.99
God's Maps: Stories of Inspiration and Direction for Motorcycle Riders Amazon.com Services LLC
Great American Motorcycle Tours
-72%
$6.18 $21.99
Great American Motorcycle Tours -OnTimeBooks-
Mini First Aid Kit - 120 Piece Small Waterproof Hard Shell Medical Kit for Car, Home, Office, Travel, Camping, Sports, Outdoor, School - Emergency First Aid Supplies and Survival Kit (Red)
-24%
$12.95 $16.95
Mini First Aid Kit - 120 Piece Small Waterproof Hard Shell Medical Kit for Car, Home, Office, Travel, Camping, Sports, Outdoor, School - Emergency First Aid Supplies and Survival Kit (Red) Atickyaid US
Great Motorcycle Tours of Europe
$29.99
Great Motorcycle Tours of Europe Amazon.com
Egofine 46 Pieces 1/4 inch Drive Socket Ratchet Wrench Set, with Bit Socket Set Metric and Extension Bar for Auto Repairing and Household, with Storage Case
-27%
$18.97 $25.83
Egofine 46 Pieces 1/4 inch Drive Socket Ratchet Wrench Set, with Bit Socket Set Metric and Extension Bar for Auto Repairing and Household, with Storage Case Egofine
General Medi Mini First Aid Kit, 110 Piece Small First Aid Kit - Includes Emergency Foil Blanket, Scissors for Travel, Home, Office, Vehicle, Camping, Workplace & Outdoor (Red)
-31%
$13.88 $19.99
General Medi Mini First Aid Kit, 110 Piece Small First Aid Kit - Includes Emergency Foil Blanket, Scissors for Travel, Home, Office, Vehicle, Camping, Workplace & Outdoor (Red) General Medi
Car First Aid Kits 275Pcs Survival Gear Home Travel Size Small Emergency Kit Tactical Hiking EVA Camping Essentials Backpack Sports Office Boat Urgent Accident
$22.99 ($0.08 / Count)
Car First Aid Kits 275Pcs Survival Gear Home Travel Size Small Emergency Kit Tactical Hiking EVA Camping Essentials Backpack Sports Office Boat Urgent Accident First Aid Kit Medical
Mini First Aid Kit, 100 Pieces Water-Resistant Hard Shell Small Case - Perfect for Travel, Outdoor, Home, Office, Camping, Hiking, Car (Black)
$13.99 ($0.14 / Count)
Mini First Aid Kit, 100 Pieces Water-Resistant Hard Shell Small Case - Perfect for Travel, Outdoor, Home, Office, Camping, Hiking, Car (Black) THRIAID
Ultimate Motorcycle Tours
-37%
$18.96 $29.99
Ultimate Motorcycle Tours Amazon.com
EVERLIT 250 Pieces Survival First Aid Kit IFAK EMT Molle Pouch Survival Kit Outdoor Gear Emergency Kits Trauma Bag for Camping Boat Hunting Hiking Home Car Earthquake and Adventures Od Green
-20%
$39.95 $49.95
EVERLIT 250 Pieces Survival First Aid Kit IFAK EMT Molle Pouch Survival Kit Outdoor Gear Emergency Kits Trauma Bag for Camping Boat Hunting Hiking Home Car Earthquake and Adventures Od Green EverLit Survival
Orthrus DOT Certified Dual Sport Multicam Adventure Motorcycle Helmet UV Protected Visor for Snowmobile ATV Dirt Bike Off Road (Halo,M)
-35%
$85.00 $129.99
Orthrus DOT Certified Dual Sport Multicam Adventure Motorcycle Helmet UV Protected Visor for Snowmobile ATV Dirt Bike Off Road (Halo,M) Amazon.com
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsmen Max Formula Spray Pump 40% DEET, 6-Ounce, 12-Pack ,Yellow, 72.0 Fl.Oz
$59.16 ($0.82 / Fl Oz)
Repel Insect Repellent Sportsmen Max Formula Spray Pump 40% DEET, 6-Ounce, 12-Pack ,Yellow, 72.0 Fl.Oz Amazon.com
Eagle Creek Pack-It Isolate Compression Packing Cubes for Travel Set S/M - 2 Lightweight, Water-Resistant Suitcase Organizer Bags with Compression Zip, Az Blue/Grey
-18%
$32.90 $39.95
Eagle Creek Pack-It Isolate Compression Packing Cubes for Travel Set S/M - 2 Lightweight, Water-Resistant Suitcase Organizer Bags with Compression Zip, Az Blue/Grey KMD-Goods
AMA Ride Guide to America Volume 2: More Favorite Motorcycle Tours in the USA
$26.89
AMA Ride Guide to America Volume 2: More Favorite Motorcycle Tours in the USA glenthebookseller
Apollo Tools 79 Piece Multi-Purpose SAE and Metric Tool Set with Sockets for the Garage, Home or on the Road. Includes Essential Tools for Vehicle Maintenance and Repairs - Red- DT9411
$29.99
Apollo Tools 79 Piece Multi-Purpose SAE and Metric Tool Set with Sockets for the Garage, Home or on the Road. Includes Essential Tools for Vehicle Maintenance and Repairs - Red- DT9411 Amazon.com
Oneal 2021 Sierra II Adventure Dual Sport Helmet - Flat Black - Large
-9%
$145.03 $159.99
Oneal 2021 Sierra II Adventure Dual Sport Helmet - Flat Black - Large Amazon.com
MOTEERLLU 8-22mm Universal Torx Wrench Set, Double-ended Self-tightening Adjustable Wrench Tools (2 PCS)
$8.99
MOTEERLLU 8-22mm Universal Torx Wrench Set, Double-ended Self-tightening Adjustable Wrench Tools (2 PCS) Forest-us
Motorcycle Arizona! -- A Guide to Touring Arizona by Motorcycle
$19.26
Motorcycle Arizona! -- A Guide to Touring Arizona by Motorcycle WIDE WORLD MAPS and MORE!
MMG Adult Motorcycle Off Road Helmet DOT - MX ATV Dirt Bike Motocross UTV - with Goggles (Matte Black, X-Large)
$59.90
MMG Adult Motorcycle Off Road Helmet DOT - MX ATV Dirt Bike Motocross UTV - with Goggles (Matte Black, X-Large) Powersports Depot
Protect Life First Aid Kit for Home/Business, HSA/FSA Eligible Emergency Kit | Mini Travel First Aid Kit | Camping First Aid Kit Hiking | Small First Aid Kit for Car | Survival Medical Kit - 100pcs
-31%
$17.95 $25.95
Protect Life First Aid Kit for Home/Business, HSA/FSA Eligible Emergency Kit | Mini Travel First Aid Kit | Camping First Aid Kit Hiking | Small First Aid Kit for Car | Survival Medical Kit - 100pcs Protect Life
Farm Tours (west of Boston) Bike Map
-40%
$5.37 $8.95
Farm Tours (west of Boston) Bike Map Mtn Outlet
GOYOJO 2024 Newest Digital Torque Wrench, 100Nm Max High-Precision, Professional 1/2" Drive - Essential Tool for Auto Repair, Motorcycle Maintenance, Bicycles, Home DIY Projects (1/2-100Nm)
$59.99
GOYOJO 2024 Newest Digital Torque Wrench, 100Nm Max High-Precision, Professional 1/2" Drive - Essential Tool for Auto Repair, Motorcycle Maintenance, Bicycles, Home DIY Projects (1/2-100Nm) JT MALL
EVERLIT Emergency Trauma Kit, CAT GEN-7 Tourniquet 36" Splint, Military Combat Tactical IFAK for First Aid Response, Gun Shots, Severe Bleeding Control (OD Green)
$69.95
EVERLIT Emergency Trauma Kit, CAT GEN-7 Tourniquet 36" Splint, Military Combat Tactical IFAK for First Aid Response, Gun Shots, Severe Bleeding Control (OD Green) EverLit Survival
x xotic tech Motorcycle Street Bike Helmet Cover Sleeves Cartoon Fluffy Plush Lightweight Full Face Protection Cover Accessory for Christmas Hat, Fun Riding Gear Gift w/Keychain (Green Big Eye)
$29.99
x xotic tech Motorcycle Street Bike Helmet Cover Sleeves Cartoon Fluffy Plush Lightweight Full Face Protection Cover Accessory for Christmas Hat, Fun Riding Gear Gift w/Keychain (Green Big Eye) Xotic Tech Direct
Front Runner Spare Tire Mount Braai/BBQ Grate
$259.00
Front Runner Spare Tire Mount Braai/BBQ Grate Front Runner Outfitters
ILM Dual Sport Adventure Motorcycle Helmet with Pinlock Compatible Sun Visor Snowmobile ATV Dirt Bike Off Road Casco Model WS902 (Matte Black, M)
$119.99
ILM Dual Sport Adventure Motorcycle Helmet with Pinlock Compatible Sun Visor Snowmobile ATV Dirt Bike Off Road Casco Model WS902 (Matte Black, M) ILMotor
Whimsical Gnomeo and Juliet Gnome Statue Handmade in USA Made of cast Stone Concrete Great for Indoor Our Outdoor 5 finishes Painted Stained or unpainted (Iron Stone Moss)
$62.95
Whimsical Gnomeo and Juliet Gnome Statue Handmade in USA Made of cast Stone Concrete Great for Indoor Our Outdoor 5 finishes Painted Stained or unpainted (Iron Stone Moss) Concrete Collective
Apollo Tools 56 Piece Compact SAE Auto Tool Set in Zippered Case, Small Mechanic Tool Set for Car Emergency, Motorcycle Repair on the Road, Great for Travel Tool Needs - Red - DT9774
$19.99
Apollo Tools 56 Piece Compact SAE Auto Tool Set in Zippered Case, Small Mechanic Tool Set for Car Emergency, Motorcycle Repair on the Road, Great for Travel Tool Needs - Red - DT9774 Amazon.com
Professional First Aid Kit, Trauma First Aid Kit with Labelled Compartments Molle System for Car, Hiking, Backpacking, Camping, Traveling, and Cycling[New Upgrade]
-5%
$36.98 $38.98
Professional First Aid Kit, Trauma First Aid Kit with Labelled Compartments Molle System for Car, Hiking, Backpacking, Camping, Traveling, and Cycling[New Upgrade] Homestockplus
LANSKLBD 8 Set Packing Cubes for Suitcases Travel Luggage Packing Organizers,Travel Essentials Luggage Organizer for Travel Accessories Shoe Bag Tioletry Bag Laundry Bag（Grey）
$9.99
LANSKLBD 8 Set Packing Cubes for Suitcases Travel Luggage Packing Organizers,Travel Essentials Luggage Organizer for Travel Accessories Shoe Bag Tioletry Bag Laundry Bag（Grey） LANSKLBD
YIYEIE 50Pcs Master Bike Torque Wrench Set, 1/4 Inch Drive, 10-220 IN.LB (1-24.9 Nm), Inch Pound Click Torque Wrench with Bit Sockets, 0.1 Nm Micro, 3/8 Adapter, Pro Bicycle Tool Kit for MTB
$47.99 ($0.96 / Count)
YIYEIE 50Pcs Master Bike Torque Wrench Set, 1/4 Inch Drive, 10-220 IN.LB (1-24.9 Nm), Inch Pound Click Torque Wrench with Bit Sockets, 0.1 Nm Micro, 3/8 Adapter, Pro Bicycle Tool Kit for MTB YIYEIE
Samsonite Compression Packing Bags, Plastic, Clear, 12-Piece Kit (2-Pouch/4-Carry-On/4-Large/2-X-Large
-30%
$14.00 $20.00
Samsonite Compression Packing Bags, Plastic, Clear, 12-Piece Kit (2-Pouch/4-Carry-On/4-Large/2-X-Large Amazon.com
Kärcher OC 3 Plus Mobile Outdoor Cleaner, 1.8 gal. Water Tank, Spray Gun and Hose, Battery Operated, for on-The-go Cleaning, 72 PSI
-15%
$135.99 $159.99
Kärcher OC 3 Plus Mobile Outdoor Cleaner, 1.8 gal. Water Tank, Spray Gun and Hose, Battery Operated, for on-The-go Cleaning, 72 PSI Amazon.com
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

peteb
Help! Polo Vivo 'Overheating'
2
Replies
38
Views
1K
@offroad
@
Kamanya
Thoughts on the Kove 450 Rally whilst riding through the Richtersveld
2 3
Replies
55
Views
5K
Aidan
Aidan
X
Big Boy TSR 250cc
Replies
5
Views
421
Xerowing
X
Kamanya
RAD Paarl 2024 Enduro invite... I've got some new decisions to make, dammit!
Replies
15
Views
2K
SpeedMetal
SpeedMetal
Kamanya
Ohlins TTX on a 990R
2
Replies
39
Views
4K
Kamanya
Kamanya

Latest posts

Top